Finally I decided to buy a Terratec NOXON audio. It's quite a nice device to play audio streams and what's best, it can play internet radio streams directly using an internet connection (like a DSL router)—there's no need to run a pc if you only want to listen to internet radio!

Main features

<%image(misc/noxon_sm.jpg|300|202|Terratec NOXON audio)%>

Here's a picture of the main gadget. The size is about 16 cm × 10.5 cm × 4 cm. It supports playing MP3 and WMA streams. The only network connection is WLAN. Terratec claims to support 802.11g, but just with 11 Mbit/s and WEP encryption—so it's basicly 802.11b in reality (compability of 802.11g to 802.11b is defined by the standard, isn't it?). But at least it does support 104 bit/128 bit keys.

On the picture you can easily see the biggest problem of this device: it's blue display. It looks nice, yes, but as many others on the web already pointed out: you can't read it from the distance at all! And it is pretty slow.

Further on the body look quite cheap. So even as it is silver, it doesn't fit 100% beside the display and the center speaker of my Pioneer NS-DV990, which is real aluminium (at least the front is).

The power supply unit is an external one and, as usual, a traditional one (no switching power supply), so it gets quite warm and is pretty bulky and the NOXON can't be switched off completely (see below what's all running after “switching off”). For audio input there's a stereo jack to RCA jack cable included. So no digital output, but I think you don't need this for radio streams anyway.

Experiences

<%image(misc/noxon_rc_sm.png|75|299|NOXON remote control)%>

The installation was quite painless. I had to set up my Fritz!Box SL WLAN for the WLAN and after that connecting the NOXON was not a big problem. OK, entering the WEP key using the remote control (see left) isn't much fun, but you have to do this only once, normally. ;-)

BTW, the remote control doesn't look very sophisticated but it's very functional and pretty ergonomic.

After an initial update of the list of internet radio stations you can start listening. To find a nice station you can browse by genre or by country. This takes quite a while, as there are so many stations. Once you found one just press play, after that you can save it to one of the numeric keys for very fast access or add it to the favourites. The favourites can be edited using the web interface.

Web interface?

Yes, you read correctly. The NOXON has a (very simple) web interface. There you can see firmware version, network settings, WLAN status, all network profiles, and your favourites. Unfortunately you can just edit the favourites, but no network settings. And the editing of the favourites is needed, but doesn't work very well (see below).

And I just discoverd one (not so) funny thing: you can access the NOXON even if it is switched of (but has power)! So this means, that switching off just stops playback and shuts down the display?

Quirks

The NOXON has quite some quirks. So saving favourites is not very good for many radio stations, because if the radio station is including the current artist and title the favourite will be saved using this and not the radio station name! It's even a bit worse for m3u sources, which are listed in the radio station list as well. If you save these, not the m3u will be saved, but the actual mp3 currently played! So you have to edit your favourites quite often. As I'm running Linux exclusively I just can use the web interface (it's good that this even exists). And for me it just works in 1 out of 5 times to delete or add a favourite and unfortunately you can't edit a favourite but you have to delete it first and add it again using the new name afterwards (or did I just miss something?).

The display isn't readable and much too slow. It neither plays OGG nor RealAudio streams (OK, I didn't find an interesting station just broadcasting one of this yet and all the RealAudio streams didn't sound too good anyway, but the 160 kbit/s OGG stream of Virgin Radio sounds very good). If you're browsing for a radio station and press play on a menu entry (a genre or country e.g.) the NOXON tries to play this, but it can't (this should be easy to fix). Otherwise it's nice that the stream is not stopped while you're looking for another station.

One nice thing to know is, that if you press the “i” button you can easily switch back to the menu where you've been before, but if you press the radio browsing button, you'll always start from the begining! If you want to test some stations it's nice to remember that. ;-)

Another “quirk” is, that there hasn't been a firmware update yet, though Terratec says that the NOXON can update itself over WLAN directly. But hey, this is only a feature, if it is used.

And please, shutdown the WLAN module on switch off in a new firmware release! True, this way the NOXON is already connected on switch on, but I don't think thats needed.

Further it would be nice to have the last station played on switch on and then to display the info screen (or at least an option to activate this).

Conclusion

It's a nice device for me, but it's clearly still a geeky gadget. I didn't test to replay streams served by my computer, but as others wrote, this works using Linux as well (Terratec even provides some documentation how to set up this). I rather listen to my CDs and SACDs directly. What I really like, is, that this is an audio only device and that it can play internet radio streams without additional software on a pc (there're not so many devices which can do that). I decided not to buy the Philips Streamium SL 400i as this gadget needs a TV at least for setup (and I don't have one). The SL 300i is even worse: there's no display integrated and you need a TV anytime to run it.

For my next big HiFi investment it would be nice to have an integrated system playing CDs, SACDs, DVDs, radio (digital and analog), as well as MP3s, and OGGs (files and streams) whith LAN and WLAN integration. So Pionieer: how about a NS DV995 available as upgrade to the NS DV990 without speaker (but a new display for more information)? I know, the NS DV990 isn't sold in Germany any longer, but in America as HTZ-940DV it's the top home theater sytem currently…

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://blog.foto-cs.de/mt-tb.cgi/77

11 Comments

A workaround to solve the quirky favorite saving: Don't save while playing! If you stop the playback and push the favorite button on the remote, the correct fav will be saved.

Now that the Noxon2 has been announced, I fear that WPA compatibility for the original model will never come. I've been waiting for this for ages too... and maybe a search function would be useful too.

I fear too, that there'll never be an update to the firmware. I'd like a better working web interface e.g. and WPA would be very good as well (currently it's just not correct, that the NOXON isn't a security risk; it is, because you have to open your WLAN a bit)



And supporting more than MP3 radio streams would be nice (the announced update to the NOXON2 is supposed to add playback of WMA radio streams at least). Unfortunately one radio station I listened quite frequently stopped their MP3 streaming recently...



At least the new service at http://radio567.com/ is interesting. It's working much better than the integrated favourite handling.

There is something strange with this device. Though I'm not sure it is a bug, when you switch the device off and come back, say, a few days later, the system does not play anything anymore. I could fix only by editing a profile and saving to another one and , important, by switching WEP from Yes to No and then to Yes again. So this seems to be a problem of the Configuration. Another problem is , though some radios are showed in the database on the web, they are not in the list in the device.



To summarize all the critics are true, I'm a little bit disappointed because of the cheap look, lack of buttons (what if the remote control breaks !!) and the bug with WEP key. And this is not a cheap device.

Luckily I didn't observe anything like that, yet, and my device was switched off once or twice for some days ;-). But I never removed the power plug and my DSL/WLAN router was always on...



I'm most angry about the non-existent support at Terratec. No firmware update in the last years, but quite a few bugs! Today I wouldn't recommend buying a Terratec product (I know I won't buy any of their products if there are alternatives). I'd rather have a look at a Squeezebox 3 of Slimdevices (http://slimdevices.com). It's quite a bit more expensive, though (and has no buttons either if that's a priority for you)...

"It neither plays OGG nor RealAudio streams (OK, I didn't find an interesting station just broadcasting one of this yet and all the RealAudio streams didn't sound too good anyway, but the 160 kbit/s OGG stream of Virgin Radio sounds very good)." Well! In the UK, BBC only broadcast their BBC Radio 1 to 4, four of the most popular national radio stations in Real Audio format. I am sure more than 90% of the UK radio-listenning population will love to listen to this stations. Choosing an Internet Radio that doesn't support Real Audio means saying good-bye to these quality stations forever.

I have a problem at installation: After the wizard is through, the unit restarts as it should. However, the Noxon displays my networks correct name, but never locks on to it. Instead, after a few seconds, the wizard starts over again from the top. Any clues? No WEP engaged.

I totally agree with all above. I feel a bit stupid having got this crappy non-supported device instead of the very-much-so supported devices from for example slim devices. They give three four new firmware versions every year - and I'm talking about one of their first products. That's as old as the noxon audio.



Sad to say it's the worst gadget I ever bought.

I also have the WEP bug problem. When i disconnect the wep security in the dlink router, the noxon connects to it and works fine. When I activate the wep security in the dlink router and put the wep code in the noxon, it refuses to connect to the dlink router. very strange... Even stranger is that the noxon connects fine with anaother router with WEP security. Anyone a solution for this irritating problem.

I also agree with all the above. What's really annoying me is that no downloadable software is available anymore on the Terratec website. It seems they want to deny that they ever produced the thing. However it is basically the same as the Philips SLA5500. I tried to upgrade the Noxon with the Philips firmware but no luck . It says it is another hardware version. So it seem we will be stuck with the “quirks” One conclusion; never Terratec for me again.

Well, despite the well reported problems and foibles this thing only cost me about 32Euros so I'm not complaining!

Leave a comment